Talk to anyone who’s been to Turtle’s Tap (152 E. Main St.) in Dwight, and it seems that they have nothing but good things to say about the bar and restaurant.
“Turtle’s is the best!” a reader named Rose told me. “My hubby and I go there often since we live in Limestone and it’s faster to get to Dwight than to … the mall!”
“Great food,” a reader named Lori wrote via email. “The best thing we like, besides the atmosphere of all the famous turtles, is the salad, which has pepperoni in it.”
After hearing such good things, I was excited to have dinner there, and I wasn’t disappointed. The salad that Lori referred to, which is a house specialty, was indeed wonderful. It comes with a sweet and creamy Italian dressing that’s so popular the restaurant sells it by the pint. Also, my super-crispy and juicy beer-battered fried chicken was excellent.
It was hard to save room for dessert, but I had been forewarned about the skillet cookie. It’s a large chocolate chip cookie cooked in a cast-iron skillet, then topped with vanilla ice cream, caramel, chocolate sauce, whipped cream and pecans. (Yes, it’s every bit as good as it sounds.) The skillet arrives hot at your table, and as you can likely imagine, the warm cookie paired with the cold ice cream and sweet toppings makes for a heavenly end to any meal. The original size was more than enough for two people, and it’s also available in individual and children’s portions.
Besides the food, Turtle’s is also famous for its murals. Covering one full wall of the restaurant is a scene of deceased celebrities sitting at a bar — what Turtle’s Tap might look like in Heaven, I’m told. Recent additions to the scene are Farrah Fawcett and Michael Jackson, who were added within a week of their passing. Owner Kevin Kropel decides which celebrities earn a spot on the wall, and he’s also chosen to have two not-so-famous figures commemorated there: his father, and a long-time Turtle employee who also was a close friend.
Opposite the mural of famous people is a mural of a giant turtle. Both are the work of local artist Steve Connor, and they contain a few surprises if you look closely. I don’t want to give away the secrets, but the drawings of Michael Jackson, Dale Earnhardt and the giant turtle are among the sketches with unusual detail.
The restaurant is named after Kropel, who is the youngest of four children. Early in life his siblings dubbed him “Turtle” for his poky pace, and the name stuck. Kropel opened the restaurant in Dwight in 1985 and later opened a location in Morris.
Turtle’s is open for lunch and dinner Tuesday through Saturday. Lunch is served from 11 a.m. to 1:30 p.m. Dinner is served from 5 to 8 p.m. Tuesday through Thursday, 5 to 9 p.m. on Friday and 4:30 to 9 p.m. on Saturday.
Turtle’s is on the east side of Main Street. When you first enter you’ll be in the bar area, but take a few steps to your left and you’ll be in a bright, spacious dining room with ample seating. For more information, call (815) 584-3663.