Friends told me about the second-to-last column by Colleen Loggins in which she addressed women who are highly educated who choose to become stay-at-home mothers. Colleen stated that she thought it is a waste to go through all that education and then not use by staying at home with your kids.
When I looked it up on the Journal’s website, man-o-man, was there a slew of comments. Many of which were not flattering to the writers.
People noted that Colleen has no right to make such statements as she is NOT a mother. Some of them questioned her future mothering abilities. (Not cool, people. That is one thing I hate about these internet comments on news stories. You can hide behind some fake name and spew hatred.)
The gist of what Colleen wrote was that it is wrong for those of us women who are highly educated to waste our education and talents by staying at home. Because none of us can predict the future, she stated it is good for women to be working parents in case anything should happen to our husbands – be it divorce or death.
What is irksome is that Colleen is half right.
It is my opinion that Colleen cannot fathom why anyone who has worked hard through college and any graduate studies would give up that to be a stay at home parent. Four to eight years of studying suddenly goes down the drain because you have decided to become a stay-at-home-mom (SAHM).
I am twenty years older than Colleen and I have four children. I have worked outside of the home, worked out of the home, had part-time jobs to survive and been a stay-at-home-mom. I have been on all sides of the coin and there is no escape from parenting guilt. No matter if you are working outside the home or staying with the kids, there is always guilt of some sort for what you are not doing.
Granted, motherhood should put us women up for sainthood. There is so much cleaning and cooking and playing and lack of sleep. You are trying to keep toddlers out of trouble and fed. Trying to get them toilet trained and learn their letters. I spent years being able to sleep anywhere at the drop of a hat because I was exhausted. That should not be a badge of honor.
One of the things you lose immediately as a SAHM is credibility except with other mothers. They know what you are doing everyday but strangers you meet at your husband’s work parties blow you off because you are only a stay-at-home-mom. People didn’t want to talk to me as a stay-at-home-mom but they could talk to me when they learned I reviewed movies for a living. Suddenly, I was ‘interesting.’
And don’t let others try to tell you the SAHM world is not competitive, it is. Who volunteers the most, who makes the best treats, who is staying sane without prozac, who still looks like they did before they had kids. The competitive zeal you had as a student and a worker does not go away and it will be directed in another venue. Look at every helicopter parent you have ever known and say that is not a part of the mix.
Don’t jump on Colleen because she dared to speak some truth. She did it without the experience as a parent to back it up. However, we don’t know what else she might have seen in her life to lead to that opinion. Perhaps she was raised by a mother or had friends who were raised by mothers with no choice in getting to stay home. My mother made it clear to me that I should always be prepared to work to support myself in case my spouse turned out to be a lay-a-bout.
What Colleen does not yet understand is a mother’s love that drives her home, if possible. That your talents can be re-directed to help your school or church. That those years are precious and it is possible to be trained in new skills when you are ready to go back to work. She hasn’t done it yet and should not be yelled at for her lacks. Would that encourage you to be better after being yelled at in the manner some people yelled at Colleen?
There are books, such as Comback Moms by Monica Samuels and J.C. Conklin, that show it can be done, that you can have both worlds. How you do it might differ from other people but you can learn a lot by finding out how other make the transition from work to being a SAHM to working again.
Maybe you can not do it all at the same time but it is possible. Have you been able to do it?
Karyn Bowman lives in Kankakee County with her outdoor writer husband and four children. Send an e-mail to momgoestothemovies@sbcglobal.net.